ShareGate alternative: a cheaper, remediation‑first option, coming soon
Updated October 2026 · 9 min read
Why you might look for a ShareGate alternative
ShareGate is a mature, well‑respected migration tool. It has a solid pre‑migration assessment, good throughput on Microsoft's Migration API, and reliable preservation of metadata and version history. If you're a large enterprise with a dedicated migration budget and a team to drive it, it's a safe, capable choice.
Two things may lead a smaller team to look elsewhere. The first is price: ShareGate's starting price, given above, is a line item to weigh for an MSP that runs a handful of migrations, or an SMB doing a one‑off move off an ageing file server. The second — and the one that costs you time rather than money — is the state of the file server itself: the four problems below.
The four things that actually break a file‑to‑SharePoint migration
Migrations die on the same four issues. Understanding them is the key to choosing the right alternative.
1. Broken permissions and ownership
A file server that's been running for a decade accumulates a mess of NTFS permissions: explicit ACLs that override inheritance, folders owned by long‑gone administrators, and layers of "just give them access for now" exceptions. SharePoint doesn't use NTFS rights — it uses permission levels — so every migration needs a mapping. Microsoft's documentation for its own SharePoint Migration Tool, for example, says three kinds of permission are migrated from a file share (Read, Write and Full control), that special permissions such as Deny are not saved, and that content under an explicit Deny may become accessible. Left unchecked, you find out weeks later when someone can see a folder they shouldn't.
2. Paths over the 400‑character limit
SharePoint in Microsoft 365 does not accept a file path, file name included, of more than 400 characters. Deep folder trees — "Clients \ 2019 \ Project \ Correspondence \ Final \ Signed \ …" — blow straight past that. Windows tolerates long paths; SharePoint does not, so those files are refused at upload and left behind.
3. Locked and open files
Any file that's open at copy time — a database, a PST, a document someone forgot to close — can't be read normally. Files left out for that reason have to be found and re‑migrated afterwards, and you have to hope you catch them all.
4. Orphaned and deleted SIDs
Ex‑staff and deleted groups leave their security identifiers (SIDs) scattered across ACLs. The accounts behind them are gone, so there is nobody to match them to, and permissions and file attribution break unless each one is dealt with.
What ShareGate's own documentation says
- Permissions: ShareGate's help article on file‑share permissions (25 May 2026) says users and groups are mapped automatically, and that files and folders with custom permission levels at the source migrate with broken inheritance at the destination and keep their permission levels. It adds that special permission levels are not supported: only permissions with one of the standard access levels (Full Control, Contribute, Read & execute, Read, Write) are migrated.
- Long paths: ShareGate's source analysis shows an error where a path is too long for any SharePoint list or library, and a warning where it is approaching the limit (help article dated 13 December 2024). For the remedies, see its documentation.
- Price: ShareGate's pricing page gives a starting price of US$5,995 for the Essentials plan, for tenants of up to 250 employees, with one workstation to run migrations (read 6 October 2026).
None of this makes ShareGate a bad tool. It is what its own documentation says, and it is worth reading against the state of your own file server.
What Approdo is being built to do: remediation‑first
Approdo is being built with the remediation inside the migrator. The Deckhand, Approdo's on‑prem agent, surveys your shares, then automatically:
- takes ownership and standardises NTFS permissions, repairing broken inheritance;
- finds over‑length paths and proposes shorter names, in a plan you review, edit and approve before anything is renamed, with every rename logged;
- will capture locked and open files via a VSS snapshot, so in‑use files migrate instead of being skipped;
- detects and remediates orphaned SIDs, remapping where it can and safely dropping the rest with an audit trail.
Only then does it migrate — straight from your server to your SharePoint, through Microsoft's own upload interfaces. Approdo is in build. What it will carry from your file server is being listed item by item, with what cannot be carried and why. Nothing on that list has yet been proven on a test.
Feature comparison
| Capability | ShareGate | Approdo |
|---|---|---|
| Pre‑migration assessment | ✓ | ✓ |
| Auto‑fix permissions / ownership | Users and groups mapped automatically; special permission levels not supported | ✓ |
| Fix 400‑char long paths | Flagged by its source analysis; see ShareGate's documentation for the remedies | ✓ |
| Capture locked / open files | See ShareGate's documentation | At launch: VSS |
| Remediate orphaned SIDs | See ShareGate's documentation | ✓ |
| Preserve metadata + versions | ✓ | Being listed, not yet proven |
| Price | Starting at US$5,995 (Essentials plan) | Free → £3,995/yr |
ShareGate's column is taken from ShareGate's own pages, read on 6 October 2026 (help.sharegate.com, sharegate.com/products/sharegate-migrate and sharegate.com/pricing). Its price is the starting price the pricing page gives for the Essentials plan, in US dollars; the page offers terms of one, two or three years. Where a cell points you to a vendor's documentation, we make no statement about that row. Approdo's column shows what it is being built to do: none of it has yet been proven on a test, and its prices are indicative. Confirm current pricing with each vendor.
Pricing: Approdo vs ShareGate
ShareGate's starting price is given above; its pricing page offers subscription terms of one, two or three years. Approdo is not on sale yet; its planned launch pricing (indicative) is:
- Assess & Preview — Free: at launch you'll run the Deckhand agent, scan unlimited data, and see a dry‑run of every fix. No card.
- Project — £0.30/GB (or £595 per file server ≤500 GB): ideal for one‑off moves.
- Pro — £1,950/yr: unlimited data, three agents.
- MSP / Partner — £3,995/yr: unlimited client tenants, the Harbour multi‑tenant console and white‑label reports, for your whole book of clients.
How an Approdo migration works
Three phases, most of it hands‑off: Survey (inventory and readiness report) → Remediate (the auto‑fixes above, previewed and logged) → Migrate (upload through Microsoft's own interfaces, delta re‑sync, clean cutover, audit report). You can read the detail on the how it works page.
Is Approdo the right ShareGate alternative for you?
If you're an enterprise with constant, large‑scale tenant‑to‑tenant work and a team already trained on ShareGate, stick with what works. If you're an MSP migrating client file servers to SharePoint, or an SMB doing a one‑off move, and you want the permissions, long paths and locked files fixed as part of the move — Approdo is being built for you.
Approdo is coming soon
Register your interest to be first to run the Deckhand, get a readiness report and a dry‑run of every fix before you pay a penny.
Register your interest →FAQ
What is the best cheaper alternative to ShareGate?
That depends on what holds your migration up. If it is the state of the file server, look at a remediation‑first tool: one built to fix the permission, long‑path and locked‑file problems before it moves anything. Approdo is being built as exactly that, with a free assessment and indicative annual tiers from £1,950/yr. ShareGate's pricing page gives a starting price of US$5,995 for its Essentials plan (read 6 October 2026).
Is ShareGate worth it for a small business or MSP?
For constant enterprise migrations, yes. For an occasional MSP or SMB migration, it depends on the size of the job: ShareGate's pricing page gives a starting price of US$5,995 for its Essentials plan (read 6 October 2026). Approdo is being built for occasional MSP and SMB migrations, with indicative per‑project and annual pricing.
Does ShareGate fix permissions and long paths automatically?
Here is what ShareGate's own documentation says. For permissions: users and groups are mapped automatically, and files and folders with custom permission levels at the source keep their permission levels, with inheritance broken at the destination; special permission levels are not supported, and only permissions with a standard access level are migrated. For paths that are too long: its source analysis shows an error where a path is too long for any SharePoint list or library; for the remedies, see its documentation. Approdo is being built to find over‑length paths, propose shorter names and apply the plan you approve.